Persuasion or Manipulation: Where I Draw the Line
Ethical marketing and sales for small business owners: a simple test for telling honest persuasion from manipulation, and what to fix if you fail it.
The first version of this post, from 2018, opened by saying marketing is manipulation. That's the wrong way to put it. Marketing is persuasion. The difference matters, and customers can feel it.
Here's how I'd put it now. Persuasion helps someone make a decision that's good for them. Manipulation gets a decision that's good for you, at their expense.
We've all been on the wrong end of it. The high-pressure sales desk where you finally say yes just to make it stop. You bought something, but you didn't trust anyone afterward. That's a sale you'll never get twice.
A simple test: the Manipulation Matrix
Nir Eyal, in his book Hooked, lays out a tool he calls the Manipulation Matrix. It asks the maker two questions:
- Would I use this myself?
- Will it materially improve the lives of the people who use it?
Your answers put you in one of four boxes.
Facilitator: yes and yes
You'd use it, and it helps people. This is where you want to be. Be honest, though. If you have to talk yourself into the answer, you're not here.
Peddler: helps people, but you wouldn't use it
Your intentions are good, but you're guessing at what the customer wants. This is where a lot of advertising goes wrong. Marketers who'd never buy the product try to imagine someone who would, and it shows.
Entertainer: you'd use it, but it doesn't improve anyone's life
Nothing wrong with that. Fun is a real product. Just know it fades fast, so you'll need to keep refreshing it to hold attention.
Dealer: no and no
You wouldn't use it and it doesn't help anyone. You're counting on people getting hooked. Don't be here. If you are, change the product.
Where I draw the line in sales and marketing
The matrix is about the product. Here's my checklist for how you sell it:
- Would you be fine if the customer saw exactly how you did it? If not, don't do it.
- No fake urgency. If the deadline isn't real, don't invent one.
- No pressure past a no. A yes you got by wearing someone down isn't a customer. It's a refund waiting to happen.
- Say who it's not for. Telling someone they don't need you builds more trust than any ad.
- Sell what you'd buy. If you wouldn't pay for it, figure out why before you ask anyone else to.
The takeaway
Run your product through the two questions. Then run your sales process through the checklist. If you don't like where you land, fix the offer before you spend another dollar promoting it.
